Middle River Dispatches

A gumbo of fly-fishing, conservation, politics and days afield, for what it is worth....

  • Front Page
  • Conservation
    • The Roosevelt Mandate
      • The Roosevelt Mandate Articles
  • Fly Fishing
    • Fly Fish Virginia
    • Fly Fishing Instruction
    • Tenkara
    • Mossy Creek Fly Fishing
  • Politics
  • Antics
    • Why
    • Who is Tom Sadler
      • Biography of G. J. Thomas Sadler, Jr.
    • Contact Information
  • Fine Print
    • Privacy Policy
      • Privacy and Unicorns
    • Terms of Use
    • Disclosures
You are here: Home / Conservation / Bristol Bay / Pebble Mine – Murkowski Appropriations Statement

Bristol Bay / Pebble Mine – Murkowski Appropriations Statement

November 24, 2020 By Tom Sadler

There continues to be a fair amount of discussion about the fate of the Pebble mine. One development worth looking at carefully is the statement Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski, who chairs the Senate’s Interior Appropriations committee, included with the committee’s bill.

EXPLANATORY STATEMENT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR, ENVIRONMENT, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS BILL, 2021
SUMMARY OF BILL

Protection of Resources in Bristol Bay, Alaska.—The Committee continues to monitor the Federal permitting process for the proposed Pebble mine project in southwest Alaska, including the efforts of the Department of the Interior, EPA, and independent subject matter experts to help protect the world-class ecosystem and salmon fishery in the Bristol Bay region from unavoidable adverse impacts. The Committee concurs with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ [Corps] assessment of August 24, 2020, that ‘‘the project, as proposed, cannot be permitted under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act’’ and appreciates the administration’s commitment to a decision guided by sound science.

The Committee notes that on August 20, 2020, the Corps separately sent a letter to the Pebble Limited Partnership outlining mitigation requirements for the project. The Corps requested a mitigation plan within 90 days that addresses both in-kind and compensatory requirements, which the Committee believes set an appropriately high bar for this unique project. In the absence of a valid mitigation plan that has received all necessary approvals at the Federal and State levels, the Committee urges the agencies to continue to withhold the applicant’s Clean Water Act permit.

If the Pebble Limited Partnership is unable to provide a full and functional compensatory mitigation plan that meets all requirements within the Corps’ requested 90-day timeframe, the Committee encourages the agencies to proceed to a decision denying the permit for the project.

Reaction from the folks who work on this issue day-to- day were not especially laudatory of the action.

I think if we would’ve seen something that essentially recommended no spending be allowed in the next fiscal year to move forward with the Pebble project, that would’ve been a little more reassuring. But this doesn’t do that,” Bristol said. “It just seems to sort of describe the situation as it is right now.”

Tim Bristol, executive director of SalmonState

According to an Associated Press report, Murkowski spokeswoman Karina Borger said the senator wanted the Corps to know it must hold the mitigation plan to a high standard and Pebble should end the process if the requirements cannot be met.

The language is a clear shot across the bow of the EPA. Hopefully, with the election behind us the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will let science rather than politics drive the decision. But if you are following the news you know anything could happen and the administration may decide to flip off the myriad interests who oppose this project.

We will have to wait and see what the Corps decides to do with Pebble’s mitigation plan. The people I talk to say the bar set by Corps is almost impossible to meet. If the Corps accepts it, and it doesn’t “provide a full and functional compensatory mitigation plan that meets all requirements” the ball will be in Senator Murkowski’s court.

Time will tell. In the meantime it can’t hurt to send a message to Senator Murkowski.

Sources:
https://www.murkowski.senate.gov/press/release/murkowski-unveils-interior-environment-bill-
https://apnews.com/article/alaska-bills-lisa-murkowski-appropriations-5199732752e804c15e0c0b8854171e2d
https://www.alaskapublic.org/2020/11/10/murkowskis-latest-pebble-action-disappoints-mine-opponents/

Filed Under: Conservation, Marine, The Roosevelt Mandate Articles Tagged With: appropriations, Bristol Bay, Murkowski, Pebble Mine

Have something to say?

You can start a conversation or join one on our forum. I call it the campfire.
You can support truth and defend wild nature by investing in Mountain Journal today. Your support comes at a critical time for nonprofit journalism - and for Greater Yellowstone. Please make a tax-deductible donation at support MoJo.

Article Sections

  • The Roosevelt Mandate Articles
  • Fly Fish Virginia
  • Fly Fishing Instruction

Categories

No cheating!

Creative Commons License
Middle River Dispatches by Tom Sadler is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Copyright © 2021 ·News Pro Theme · Genesis Framework by StudioPress · WordPress · Log in